Entities

Facs

Tillich Lectures

Transcript

[578]

except in some radical philosophical materialists at the end of the 18th century in France, where ethics itself were identified with the fulfillment of the most rudimentary desires and strivings.

The third concept of materialism is historical materialism, which has nothing to do with these two other meanings. It has nothing to do with the first meaning. In one of the most important early writings called the c, d has expressed his radical and monumental criticism of metaphysical materialism.1 And it was only later, through his friend g, and through the general development of the second half of the 19th century, that elements of metaphysical materialism came into the movement which called itself “Marxist”. In principle these two things have nothing to do with each other.

Now what is the meaning of historical materialism? The meaning is that the act of production and reproduction of one's physical existence is the basis from which all other activities must be understood and derived. The way in which the fundamental desires of reproduction of our existence in time and space are satisfied is, at the same time, the way in which all cultural creativities are to be interpreted. Special artistic forms are expressions, in this view, of a special society which is either aristocratic or bourgeois or proletarian, and so of course equally the religious ideas and the philosophical ideas. This derivation is the essence of historical materialism.

Now the demonic trick of propaganda has identified the historical materialism, which is a method of understanding man's cultural creativity, with the moral materialism which is a derogatory statement for everybody and by everybody, and with metaphysical materialism which


Footnotes, Editorial notes

1 In the Thesen über Feuerbach (Spring 1845; published posthumously in 1888 by Friedrich Engels), Marx extends his critique of idealism to include “old” materialism (Thesis 1 [MEW III, 5]: “Der Hauptmangel alles bisherigen Materialismus [den Feuerbach’schen mit eingerechnet], ist, daß der Gegenstand, die Wirklichkeit, Sinnlichkeit nur unter der Form des Objekts oder der Anschauung gefaßt wird; nicht aber als sinnlich menschliche Tätigkeit, Praxis; nicht subjektiv. […].”). / “The main flaw of all previous materialism [including that of Feuerbach] is that the object, reality, and sensuousness are grasped only in the form of the object or of intuition; but not as sensuous human activity, practice; not subjectively. […]”). This is also referred to as contemplative or metaphysical materialism. The contemplative, theoretical conception of reality and of human beings is contrasted with a practical one. People create, as it were, their own social reality themselves as the totality of their respective social relations. Linked to this is, on the one hand, a critique of politics—even educators are subject to change—as well as of philosophy to date: “Die Philosophen haben die Welt nur verschieden interpretiert, es kömmt aber darauf an, sie zu verändern.” / “Philosophers have merely interpreted the world in various ways; the point, however, is to change it.” (11th Thesis).

Register

aEthics
bMaterialism
cMarx, Thesen über Feuerbach, None
dMarx, Karl
eMetaphysics
fMaterialism
gEngels, Friedrich
hCulture
iCreativity
jReligion
kMaterialism
lCulture
mCreativity
nCreativity
oMetaphysics
pMaterialism

Entities

Keywords

Persons

Literature

TL-0583.pdfTL-0582.htmlTL-0584.html