Entities

Facs

Tillich Lectures

Transcript

[553]

Let's go into some of these examples. Not many of you are able even to understand why a man like a could become ultimate authority for a whole nation of comparatively educated people. He could because of an ideology in which the participation in this nation was a participation in a sacramental unity. I come back to these points later when we speak about conformism, and also politics. I had a friend1, perhaps the most intelligent professor of theology—we studied together—and when the Nazis came I turned against them and he turned for them. This was an act which for me was hard to understand, but in his very first book, which appeared already in the year 1933, when h came to power, he explained it, and his explanation was of real theological weight and made him the Nazi theologian for the whole period, namely he identified the national community with a sacramental community. For him, the blood community of the nation had sacramental character. And now he construed i as the voice of God which has the same ultimate authority as the Bible for orthodox Protestants, and the Pope has for orthodox Catholics. The basis was a religious one. And in the moment in which you accept the identity of nation (from the point of view of blood, especially, as he did) and sacramental community, then it is quite possible to establish an authority in principle, namely he through whom the unconscious meaning of this nation speaks, and voice-of-God then means that this unconscious meaning has an ultimate dimension. So we have here an authority which cannot be criticized any more because it has sacramental consecration.

Now let's take the Protestants. Of course this ultimate authority broke down when it was clear that it was a demonic seduction of the German people into a self-destructive self-elevation


Footnotes, Editorial notes

1 This refers to f (1888–1972) programmatic text Das kirchliche Wollen der Deutschen Christen. Zur Beurteilung des Angriffs von Karl Barth (Theologische Existenz heute, München 1933). Hirsch objects to Barth’s view of ecclesiastical order—which he considers ahistorical—and to Barth’s “Polemik […] wider die Forderung der Deutschen Christen […], den Ruf Gottes in der Stunde der nationalsozialistischen Revolution, den Auftrag unsers Herrn an seine Kirche in dem großen Geschehen unsrer Tage zu hören.“ This German-nationalist argumentation continues in the work Die gegenwärtige geistige Lage im Spiegel philosophischer und theologischer Besinnung. Akademische Vorlesungen zum Verständnis des deutschen Jahres 1933 (Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, Göttingen 1934) just one year later. Tillich, who had emigrated in 1933, responded in the journal Theologische Blätter (1934) with the famous Die Theologie des Kairos und die gegenwärtige geistige Lage. Offenen Brief an Emanuel Hirsch von Paul Tillich vom 1.10.1934 (EN 6, 143–176#). In it, he criticizes his childhood friend and his ethno-political theology, which he argues transforms religious socialism into religious nationalism: “Du verkehrst die prophetisch-eschatologisch gedachte Kairos-Lehre in priesterlich-sakramentale Weihe eines gegenwärtigen Geschehens.“ (152#) This led to a rift between the two. Hirsch had also apparently served as a secret evaluator for measures aimed at bringing people into line and for denunciations, thereby retroactively legitimizing Tillich’s forced emigration and also denouncing Karl Barth.

Register

aHitler, Adolf
bAuthority
cNation
dIdeology
eSacramental_community
fHirsch, Emanuel
gNazism
hHitler, Adolf
iHitler, Adolf
jAuthority
kDemonic

Entities

Keywords

Persons

TL-0558.pdfTL-0557.htmlTL-0559.html