Entities

Facs

Tillich Lectures

Transcript

[121]

calculations to everything living, and to a certain extent (I come more to this later) even to the psychology of man. There is a level in which mechanical calculation is justified. But what is not justified is the universalization of this mechanical experimentation, which is very important for a limited level.

Now everything is all right and theologians rejoice. They rejoice especially if Mr. a tells them that there is in physics a principle of indeterminacy, and if even the great b writes a little book on human freedom.1 “Now science has justified us”, many theologians say—you can read that in a lot of books—“and we don’t have to fear any more these bad people from d to e to these present day materialists.”

The situation is not as nice as this, thank heaven!, because if it were as nice as this, then the next great scientist, after Planck and Heisenberg, would perhaps discover what f—and I had a day's talk with him in the year 19322—once told me, that he knows that we are now under the theories of Planck and the principle of indeterminacy to have a universally valid and calculable universe; but he added—and he insisted on this—that it is his belief that once upon a time science will rediscover that worldview which he, Einstein, brought with him out of the 19th century. Now this prophecy has not been fulfilled, up to today, but it might be fulfilled one day—then all the poor theologians who rejoiced about the rediscovery of freedom!

Now I am very much afraid that the favorable climate in natural science, which we certainly have today, can be used in order to derive too quickly, from science, a theological statement! You cannot derive a statement in the dimension of ultimate concern from a statement


Footnotes, Editorial notes

1 This presumably refers to Max Planck’s lecture, delivered before the Leipzig Ortsgruppe of the German Philosophical Society on November 27, 1936, which was subsequently republished in several editions (Vom Wesen der Willensfreiheit, in Max Planck, Vorträge, Reden, Erinnerungen, hg. von Hans Roos und Armin Hermann [Berlin, 5d 2001], 137–154).
2 A meeting between Albert Einstein and Paul Tillich in 1932 has not yet been historically verified. Einstein and Tillich belonged to similar intellectual circles, and their exchanges are documented time and again. It is conceivable that they may have come into contact, particularly in Berlin, where Tillich had previously worked (1919–1924) and where Einstein lived (1914–1932). The year 1932 marked a turning point for both men, leading to their exile. A meeting in Davos in March 1928, during the Davos University Courses, is reliably documented. Intensive exchanges also took place later; see, for example, Tillich’s essay Das Problem des ‘persönlichen Gottes.’ Eine Auseinandersetzung mit Albert Einstein (1940) (GW 12, 300–304), written in response to a lecture on Wissenschaft und Religion given by Einstein in September 1940 in New York.

Register

aHeisenberg, Werner
bPlanck, Max
cFreedom
dLamarck, Jean-Baptiste
eDarwin, Charles
fEinstein, Albert
gScience
hFreedom
iScience
jTheology
kUltimate_Concern

Entities

Keywords

Persons

TL-0124.pdfTL-0123.htmlTL-0125.html